Fathom Favorites : New York City Bars + Cafes

1. Ginny's Supper Club

Dress to impress at this subterranean jazz venue and restaurant. The room looks good, the crowd looks good, and the music sounds good. It's that kind of Manhattan experience you picture yourself having before ever visiting the city. Upstairs is Marcus Samuelsson's Red Rooster, a hot destination for fashionable Harlemites. The bar scene up there is on point too.

310 Malcolm X Blvd.
New York, NY 10027

2. 169 Bar

A terrific old dive with all the gritty trappings you're looking for: kitschy decor, cheap shots, real characters. In a city that's becoming more and more polished, 169 has retained its edge and 100-year-old patina. Not to mention a leopard-print pool table, loud music, and fake palm trees.

169 E. Broadway
New York, NY 10002

3. Smith & Mills

The kind of bar you wish could be your local. A former stable has been turned into a quirky little gem of a watering hole — drinkers elbow to elbow, downing cocktails in coup glasses and reaching for another oyster. The bartender probably has a handlebar mustache, but this place is proto-hipster: small-batch, crafted with care, and focused on the details.

71 N. Moore
New York, NY 10013

4. Attaboy

This discreet bar on a residential street was once the speakeasy responsible for the 21st-century classic cocktail craze. The bar has moved on, but two key bartenders have stayed behind, and now craft cocktails with the same whiz-bang precision, but without the secrecy and reservation system. Mixology to the max.

134 Eldridge St.
New York, NY 10002

5. The Dead Rabbit

Dip your cup in the communal punch at The Dead Rabbit Grovery & Grog, a brand new tavern that channels old New York. The upstairs parlor focuses on 19th-century mixed drinks; the Irish taproom downstairs serves oysters, stews, pies, and beers in the Anglo-Hibernian tradition.

30 Water St.
New York, NY 10004