This massive, two-floor consignment store is the place to go in search of a hidden gem, whether that be a vintage top, a local painting, a pair of shoes, a bracelet, a tea set, or any number of quirky items unearthed from around the island. Be warned: There’s a bunch of nice furniture downstairs.
45 Victoria St.
Hamilton, HM 12
+1-441-295-5400
Bermudian artist Barbara Finsness hand-paints everything she sells — ceramics, linens, glassware, stationary, and other accessories — in colorful motifs inspired by the flora and fauna of the island. She has shops in Hamilton, St. George's, and the Fairmont Southampton.
3 Queen St.
Hamilton, HM 11
+1-441-292-5292
The authentic Bermuda short. Get one in your favorite color. They have swim trunks if you forgot yours at home.
12 Reid St.
Hamilton, HM 11
+1-441-704-8227
Bermuda writer, blogger, and local character Kristen White’s personality is on full display at her St. George’s boutique, located in historic Tucker House, where she sells all her favorites things: hula hoops, head scarves, and secondhand books included. She also runs tours of St. George’s, which depart from the shop and include a foodie bike tour and a haunted history tour that she acts in.
5 Water St.
St. George's, GE 05
+1-441-297-0448
A charming perfumery located in historic Stewart Hall that looks as nice as it smells. Come by on a Tuesday or Thursday and try your hand at making one of their only-in-Bermuda scents, which incorporate local aromatics like cedar, oleander, and loquat. Stop in on a Wednesday or Saturday for a real treat, when afternoon tea is served in the best smelling back garden ever. They also have a storefront on Hamilton's Front Street that only sells fragrance.
5 Queen St.
St.George's, GE 05
+1-441-293-0627
A hole-in-the-wall shop specializing in sustainable, vegan, zero-waste items, like smoothie bombs, local small-bach deodorant, and crystal-infused body oil from Bermudian herbal brand Àse Naturals.
49 Front St.
Hamilton, HM 11
This small shop, tucked down Hamilton’s Old Cellar Lane, deals in good vibes and great souvenirs, like soaps, candles, Bermuda-stamped totes and coasters, and dainty jewelry made by the owner herself.
47 Front St.
Hamilton, HM 11
+1-441-336-1326
A stylish new St. George’s boutique that stocks a tight selection of locally made merch (Limestone + Cedar Co. candles, Ace Boy cushions, Nawf Shore tee shirts) and stylish imports (Gestalten coffee table books, Cynthia Rowley apparel). Great for an island-inspired wardrobe update.
1 King’s Sq.
St.George's, GE 05
+1-441-703-4500
Alexandra Mosher’s jewelry business, which started as a street stall operation, now has its own fully fledged Front Street flagship selling highly giftable pink sand jewelry inspired by the ebb and flow of the island, all made by hand by the artist and her team in the back of the shop.
5 Front St.
Hamilton, HM 11
+1-441-236-9009
A treasure trove of home goods by U.S., Scandinavian, and Bermudian designers. Look out for hand-carved reclaimed wooden spoons from carpenter Alex Davidson, glass vases by Laura Elizabeth Smith, and mod jewelry from Rebecca Little, among other wares from local artisans. Bring an extra bag if you plan to shop here. You’ll want everything.
46 Par-La-Ville Rd.
Hamilton, HM 11
+1-441-296-5250
Capri-born cobbler Vincenzo Della Valle will custom-fit a one-of-a-kind Italian leather sandal to your foot in roughly an hour. Right in front of you. By the window. You’re clearly not on the Amalfi Coast (though the roads are windy and the scooters are aplenty), but in this cute little shop, it sure does feel like that way.
19 Queen St.
Hamilton, HM 11
+1-441-236-7263
Designer clothing. Boutique jewelry. Top-shelf skincare. Bermuda-made accessories. Gifts. Snacks. Wine (including Raft-Up Rosé, a Bermuda exclusive.) If you need it, they got it. If you don’t need it, you’ll probably want it. It’s just that kind of place.
9 Reid St.
Hamilton, HM 11
+1-441-296-0280
This is where the cool kids shop. Nicole Golden’ well-curated boutique brims with an eclectic mix of fashion-forward styles and vintage-inspired pieces. The emphasis is on men’s and women’s clothing, though a healthy smattering of candles, jewelry, and home goods give it wide-ranging appeal.
11 Front St.
Hamilton, HM 11
+1-441-296-3039