Fathom Favorites : Hamptons Hotels

1. The Chequit

The Chequit reopened with a chic new Hamptons-y look. After waking up in one of the thirty-seven airy, whitewashed rooms with nautical blues and little flower arrangements, you can enjoy a rustic summer breakfast on the sweeping front porch.

23 Grand Ave.
Shelter Island Heights, 11965

2. Shelter Island House

Previously known as La Maison Blanche, Shelter Island House is a pet-friendly boutique hotel with eight garden-view rooms, complimentary bicycle use, and pétanque court. Shout-out to the in-house bakery, where fresh breads and croissants are made daily.

11 Stearns Point Rd.
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

3. Baron's Cove

The newly renovated Baron's Cove hotel opened its doors last summer. Pack for prep-tastic happenings: sailing, tennis, G+Ts by the flag pole.

31 W. Water St.
Sag Harbor, NY 11963

4. Topping Rose House

A beautifully restored 1842 Greek Revival mansion is now a small luxury inn, stellar restaurant, and farm, with chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten consulting on the menu this summer. Start with a drink on the wrap-around porch before sitting down in the breezy dining room for fresh greens straight from the hotel's farm.

1 Bridgehampton – Sag Harbor Turnpike
Bridgehampton, 11932

5. Inn at Windmill Lane

Classically modern cottages and suites with ridiculously lavish amenities,: Duxiana beds, private exercise rooms, rain showers, preferred tee times at Montauk Downs Golf Club.

23 Windmill Lane
Amagansett, 11930

6. Sunset Beach

André Balazs revamps a 1960s motel as a chic summercamp for adults. It's stylish, whimsical, and somewhat secluded (aside from the raucous sunset cocktail hours).

35 Shore Rd.
Shelter Island, 11965

7. C/O The Maidstone

Scandinavian design group C/O add a fresh — and sustainable — layer of personality to the posh hotel, restaurant, and grounds. Widly decorated rooms are bursting with color, fancy bath products, and the occasional claw-footed bath tub in the middle of the room. Foodie-family friendly (dogs, too).

207 Main St.
East Hampton, NY, 11937

8. Capri

Thirty beachy guest rooms done up by the guys behind W South Beach and Suf Lodge in Montauk, a Nobu restaurant, and a shop curated by Cynthia Rowley. No doubt it's a scene, especially at The Bathing Club, the hotel's pool lounge. Prepare for beaching with cocktails in hand.

281 County Rd. 39A
Southampton, NY, 11968

9. Southampton Inn

Classic East End resort in walking distance to town. Engage in preppy Southampton pastimes (tennis, swimming, croquet, cocktailing) on five well-manicured acres. On chilly nites, cozy up to the fireplace. 

91 Hill St.
Southampton, NY, 11968

10. The Baker House 1650

Within walking distance of East Hampton village. A sunny breakfast room, pool, 200-year-old wisteria pergola. As a major bonus, guests get coveted beach parking passes.

181 Main St.
East Hampton, NY, 11937

11. American Hotel

An icon of the whaling era in a gorgeous seaside town that feels more New Englandy than the rest of the Hamptons. There are only eight guest rooms, so it's tough to book. A well-regarded restaurant lets you take a peek into the place. Service can be a little snarky.

49 Main St.
Sag Harbor, NY , 11963

12. 1708 House

An historic B&B with floral curatins, four-poster beds, wood floors, fireplaces, brick patio, and dining room with Limoges china.

126 Main St.
Southampton, NY, 11968

13. Solé East

A laid-back beach resort with nicely appointed (though not overly lavish) details like modern decor, free WiFi, heated pool, and beach barbecues. Or consider one of the 26 vintage-style rooms at the more affordable Solé East Beach (107 S. Emerson Ave.; +1-631-668-6700).

90 Second House Rd.
Montauk, NY, 11954

14. Montauk Yacht Club

Nautical inn (navy and white textiles, working lighthouse) you come to expect in a seaside town but rarely find. Play tennis on courts by the water, then repair at sundown with a cognac and cigar on the docks. A well-curated boutique of sundries and sailing bags make good souvenirs.

32 Star Island Rd.
Montauk, NY, 11954

15. Ruschmeyer's

Summer camp meets bar. A beer garden and dance floor mix with a ping pong table and teepees. Excellent Instagramming opportunities.

161 Second House Rd.
Montauk, NY, 11954

16. The Surf Lodge

One part stylish hotel, one part summer club, and one part beachfront music venue. They've hosted major talent, from Willie Nelson to St. Lucia to Ra Ra Riot.

183 Edgemere St.
Montauk, NY, 11954

17. Gurney's Montauk

Since new owners took over in 2013, the 90-year-old oceanfront resort has been undergoing a major facelift: 42 newly renovated rooms, a 30,000 square-foot spa and sand-filtered seawater pool, new dining options (The Beach Club is our favorite), and most recently Gurney's Residences opening this year.

290 Old Montauk Hwy.
Montauk, 11954