Most Popular Guides: New York, London, Paris, Rome, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Hong Kong, Rio, Amalfi Coast, The Hamptons, See All Guides

Eleven Madison Park's New NYC Menu

by Pavia Rosati

All photos by Pavia Rosati unless otherwise noted

The illustrious restaurant Eleven Madison Park debuted its new, New York-themed menu this weekend. Here's a preview.

NEW YORK CITY – For Eleven Madison Park, it wasn't enough to be considered one of the best restaurants not only in New York City but in the whole world. Nope. Chef Daniel Humm and general manager Will Guidara decided it was time to take the menu that won them seven perfect stars (four from The New York Times, three from Michelin) and toss it out the window. It was already ambitious and unusual, a grid-based menu wherein everything — four each of appetizers, first courses, mains, and desserts — was listed according the defining ingredient of the dish and changed constantly.

The new, four-hour, $195-a-head prix fixe, which debuted this weekend, is still grid-based - NYC is on a grid, after all. But they've turned up the whimsy and the drama as they aim to create a culinary experience that is as theatrical as it is gastronomic. New York City is the unifying theme, with classic and iconic foods and snacks reintepreted in unexpected ways no one would ever have imagined on Delancey Street in 1940. I got a preview a few weeks ago.

Black and White Cookies

Sold at every deli on every corner, they're twice the size of a child's hand and look like this:

Black and White Cookies

Photo: betsyweber / Flickr

At EMP, they come in a lovely box and are not in fact sugar bombs but rather savory bite-sized Parmesan cookies with a Parmesan cream filling. The glaze is black truffle and goat butter. At the end of the meal, they serve a sweet version of the black and white: a sucree cookie with lemon and chocolate glaze and apricot filling.

Black and White Cookies

Black and White Cookies

By the way, I've lived in New York for twenty years, and these were my first black and white cookies.

Appetizing Course

Jewish delicatessens are to New York City what cheese shops are to Paris. You get bagels. You get lox, the smoked salmon that you put on bagels. You get rye bread.

Bagel and Lox

Lox on an everything bagel. Photo: joebielawa / Flickr

EMP serves a smoking platter — literally, it's smoking under the glass dome — of sturgeon smoked over moss, flowers, and applewood.

Appetizing Course

Chef de cuisine James Kent explains what we're eating as the entire restuarant looks on. Yes, the photos are grainy. I'm not one of those people who thinks flash is okay.

Appetizing course

When you lift the dome, the applewood smoke infuses the air. Here's a close-up on the sturgeon above the mossy, floral goodness.

Appetizing Course

The table looks like this when they finish serving everything. At the place settings: romaine lettuce dressed with everything bagel topping (the best part!), quail eggs, and pickled shallots. On the lower right: creme fraiche topped with a layer of caviar in a caviar tin. Also on the table: homemade pickles and toasted rye bread crisps. Time to go to town.

Appetizing Course

Appetizing Course

Caviar Course

Long Island Clam Bake

A summertime staple. Usually served on the beach.

Clam bake 

Photo by arnold | inuyaki / Flickr

Here, the clam bake consists of three parts. In the pot, resting on a bed of seaweed: buckwheat clam veloute with clam juice and stock, salt cod, cream, citrus, and buckwheat kasha. In the bowl: a quenelle of buckwheat bavarois, kabocha squash, Long Island clams, and pickled honshimeji mushrooms topped with tarragon flowers, oyster vinaigrette, and tomato snow.

Clambake

On the side: zucchini bread served in corn husks. 

Corn Husk  

Egg Cream

A 1900s Brooklyn invention that nowadays rarely contains eggs or cream. A soda fountain favorite. Ask your grandfather.

Egg Cream

Photo: David Berkowitz / Flickr

Eleven Madison Park prepares it tableside from a few ingredients: orange syrup, whole milk with cocoa nibs, orange essence, and Bronx seltzer.

Egg Cream

Egg Cream

New York Cheesecake

You can top it with blueberries, strawberries, whipped cream, or nothing at all. But it usually looks like a cake.

Cheesecake

Photo by Tobyotter / Flickr

Eleven Madison Park deconstructs it into the essentials. Goat cheese, chamomile, and raspberry.

Cheesecake 

WATCH IT

See how they do it at Eleven Madison Park and The NoMad, their other restaurant.

FIND IT

Eleven Madison Park
11 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10010
+1-212-889-0905
info@elevenmadisonpark.com

MORE INFO ON THE NEW MENU

A Restaurant of Many Stars Raises the Ante

READ MORE ON FATHOM

Italy's Best Chef Tastes New York's Best Italian Food
The Goodfellas of NoMad

Pavia is the founder of Fathom. She splits her time between New York City and London but is happiest on the Sorrentine Peninsula. You can follow her at @pavianyc on Twitter, Instagram, and Pinterest. She travels for the four-hour lunches.

- Get to know her better: Fathom Questionnaire
- Read more: Fathom articles

More On Fathom

Instant in-box upgrade: Sign up for Fathom's newsletter.